March 17, 2014
Scottish crime writer McDermid (Cross and Burn) adeptly reworks Jane Austen's Gothic satire for the modern audiences. A homeschooled minister's daughter bored by the "narrow confines" of the Dorset countryside and her "deeply average and desperately dull" family, Cat is given her break when her neighbors invite her as their guest to the Edinburgh Fringe Festival. There, Cat befriends the needy Bella Thorpe who fancies Cat's brother and meets the captivating Henry Tilney, with his "heroic" face and "luxuriant honey-blond hair." Drama ensues. "When she looked back on that first meeting, Cat would wonder whether she should have been more wary of a man who began their acquaintance with such a blatant lie. For there was nothing gentle about what followed." As Cat gets acquainted with Eleanor, Henry's sister, she secures an invitation to their family home, the enchanting Northanger Abbey, a mansion of possible secrets that stirs the darkest recesses of Cat's overworked imagination. Following Austen's storyline but diverging in distinctive ways of her own, McDermid captures the naivete of the protagonist of Austen's prose, though at times her teenage characters come off as contrived in their language and behavior. Rife with conflicts of love, gossip, misunderstandings, and updates on social media, it is an accessible and enjoyable read, especially rewarding for young readers as a gateway into appreciating the classics. Agent: Jane Gregory, Gregory & Company.
April 15, 2015
Crime writer McDermid (A Place of Execution) here updates Jane Austen's early novel with smartphones, tweeting, and vampire fantasies. Naive and highly imaginative 17-year-old Cat Morland is offered the exciting opportunity to go to the monthlong Fringe Festival in Edinburgh, where she is exposed to theater and literature. There she meets two friends who compete for her attention, Bella Thorpe and Eleanor Tilney, and the requisite handsome young man who steals her heart. This rendition references Twilight and its ilk, and while this allows McDermid to write a lighter novel, it definitely is not as engaging as her mysteries. Narrator Liz Pearce gives a solid performance as the young adults in the story. VERDICT Recommended for Austen fans who enjoy vampire-centric YA. ["The marriage-mindedness of the teenage characters is harder to believe, and the black-and-white characterization of some heroes and villains is overdone. Still, McDermid's descriptions of scenery and settings are excellent, and overall this Austen experiment is a success," read the review of the Grove hc, LJ 4/1/14.]--Joyce Kessel, Villa Maria Coll., Buffalo
Copyright 2015 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.